A Cup of Crime

Cadfael · S01E01

One Corpse Too Many

First aired 1994-05-29 · Written by Russell Lewis · Directed by Graham Theakston

ByDavid

One Corpse Too Many opens the series with a murder hidden inside a massacre. In 1138 King Stephen takes the castle at Shrewsbury by siege and orders the garrison hanged. Shrewsbury Abbey is left to bury the dead, and the task of preparing the bodies falls to Brother Cadfael, a man who came to the cloister after an adventurous and far from monastic youth, much of it spent fighting as a crusader in the Holy Land.

Cadfael is told that ninety-four men were executed. He counts ninety-five. The extra man was not hanged like the others, and Cadfael realises that he has found a murder. He asks King Stephen for permission to try to solve it and receives it.

His inquiry takes in a cache of hidden treasure, Godith, the daughter of the castle's owner, who is on the run, and a young man on the rise in the district, Hugh Beringar. The film is adapted from the first of Ellis Peters's Cadfael novels, and Wikipedia describes it as keeping close to the book, with only minor changes of plot and script to suit television.

On the novel's plot the victim is a squire who was carrying his master's treasure to safety when he was killed. The murderer is Adam Courcelle, whom Hugh accuses at the King's banquet, staking his own life on the charge. The King orders trial by combat. Courcelle falls on his own dagger and dies, and Stephen rewards Hugh with the post of deputy sheriff of Shropshire.

Russell Lewis wrote the film and Graham Theakston directed it. Derek Jacobi plays Cadfael and Sean Pertwee plays Hugh Beringar, the first of three actors to take the part. Peter Copley is Abbot Heribert, Michael Culver is Prior Robert and Julian Firth is Brother Jerome, all of whom the series keeps for most of its run. Michael Grandage plays King Stephen, Christian Burgess plays Courcelle and Juliette Caton plays Godith, who is also billed as Godric.

The production was filmed mostly in Hungary, where a Shrewsbury was built because the original abbey survives only as its church. Producer Stephen Smallwood worked with executive producers Neville C. Thompson and Ted Childs. Cadfael first aired on ITV on 29 May 1994, and the series later reached American viewers on the PBS strand Mystery!.

Television Heaven, reviewing the whole series, rates the first run as probably its best. It praises this opener for setting one small death against a larger public killing without making too much of the irony. On IMDb the film is the most-voted of the thirteen, with a score of 7.7 from 458 votes.

Cast

  • Derek Jacobias Brother Cadfael
  • Sean Pertweeas Hugh Beringar
  • Peter Copleyas Abbot Heribert
  • Michael Culveras Prior Robert
  • Julian Firthas Brother Jerome
  • Christian Burgessas Adam Courcelle
  • Michael Grandageas King Stephen
  • Richard Hendersas Torold Blund
  • Juliette Catonas Godith
  • Jeremy Youngas Arnulf of Hesdin
  • Albie Woodingtonas Sergeant Warden