A Cup of Crime

Cadfael · S02E03

A Morbid Taste for Bones

First aired 1996-08-25 · Written by Christopher Russell · Directed by Richard Stroud

ByDavid

A Morbid Taste for Bones sends Brother Cadfael out of Shrewsbury and into Wales. A young monk, Brother Columbanus, has a vision, and following it the monks of Shrewsbury Abbey travel to Wales to recover the bones of St Winifred and bring them home. Their attempt to bribe the Welsh puts them at odds with the local residents, and when the local landowner is found murdered, the monks are the prime suspects. It takes Cadfael's intervention and mediation to smooth things over and let them leave.

Wikipedia says the adaptation is primarily faithful to Ellis Peters's novel, with several changes to secondary characters and names. Brother John and Annest are dropped, which leaves one set of young lovers for the viewer to follow. The tension between the Welsh villagers and the English monks is played up considerably, and the acquisition of the saint becomes more dangerous as a result.

Father Huw is recast as the suspicious and rather grubby Father Ianto, who opposes the removal of the saint and scolds the monks for haggling over her bones. Bened the smith keeps his name, but he loses much of his good nature and becomes a suspicious rival of the dead landowner, and a vehement accuser of the monks.

The climax is the most detailed part of Wikipedia's comparison. In the novel Columbanus is tricked into a confession in the dark. In the film he confesses to a fevered figure of his own imagining, egged on by Cadfael, who pretends to see a figure of light bearing down on them as they keep their vigil in St Winifred's church.

Sioned, the dead man's daughter, stays hidden as a witness. When Columbanus describes with joy how he struck her father down in the saint's name, she loses control and flies at him, with disastrous consequences. Her lover, renamed Godwin, comes to defend her, and Columbanus dies by accident.

Columbanus's reasons are less clear than they are in the book. He innocently denies any ambition to be the youngest head under a mitre, and his actions seem to come from religious fervour and criminal insanity rather than a cold bid for fame.

Christopher Russell wrote the film and Richard Stroud directed it. Anna Friel plays Sioned, John Hallam plays Lord Rhysart, Nick Patrick plays Columbanus, Ellis Jones plays Father Ianto and Stephen Moyer plays Godwin. Derek Jacobi leads, with Terrence Hardiman as Radulfus, Mark Charnock as Oswin and Michael Culver and Julian Firth as Prior Robert and Brother Jerome.

The story is the first of Ellis Peters's novels, where it introduces Cadfael, but the film is set well into Radulfus's time as abbot instead of introducing him. It was first shown on ITV on 25 August 1996, and IMDb gives it 8.0 from 292 votes.

Cast

  • Derek Jacobias Brother Cadfael
  • Michael Culveras Prior Robert
  • Julian Firthas Brother Jerome
  • Terrence Hardimanas Abbot Radulfus
  • Mark Charnockas Brother Oswin
  • Anna Frielas Sioned
  • John Hallamas Lord Rhysart
  • Nick Patrickas Brother Columbanus
  • Ellis Jonesas Father Ianto
  • Stephen Moyeras Godwin
  • Philip Rowlandsas Bened