A Cup of Crime

Cadfael · S03E02

St. Peter's Fair

First aired 1997-08-19 · Written by Russell Lewis · Directed by Herbert Wise

ByDavid

St. Peter's Fair tests the one friendship that the series has built. Brother Cadfael puts Hugh Beringar to the test, and Hugh has to choose between his loyalty to the King and his friendship with Cadfael. The film sets that choice inside a murder at the fair held every year at Shrewsbury.

The fair brings visiting merchants into the town, and the Abbey levies tolls on them. The townspeople object to those tolls, and they come into conflict with the Abbey's officers and with the merchants themselves. A curfew is ordered, but not everybody obeys it. One of the wine merchants is then murdered.

It may be a result of the scrap between the townsfolk and the merchants, or it may have a more substantial motive, and Cadfael thinks something more is going on among those who have come to the fair. IMDb sums up the film as having multiple homicides, a revolt of the local tradesmen and intrigue that strains Cadfael's friendship with Hugh.

Wikipedia singles this film out among the thirteen. It says the adaptation has a shocking twist near the end, different from the novel, that pits Cadfael and Hugh against each other, with Hugh's loyalty to King Stephen on one side and Cadfael's sense of true justice on the other. In Ellis Peters's books their friendship is never put at risk. In the film, according to Wikipedia, the two reconcile before the end of the episode.

Russell Lewis wrote the film, his fifth and last for the series, and Herbert Wise directed it. Eoin McCarthy plays Hugh Beringar. Jacqueline Defferary plays Emma Vernold, Ben Pullen plays Ivo Corbiere, Tim Wylton plays Geoffrey Corviser and Richard Clifford plays the Glover of Shotwick. Derek Jacobi leads, with Terrence Hardiman as Abbot Radulfus, Mark Charnock as Oswin, and Michael Culver and Julian Firth as Prior Robert and Brother Jerome.

It was shown on ITV on 19 August 1997, the second of three consecutive Tuesdays on which the third series went out. Albie Woodington, who plays Sergeant Warden, is listed for the film by TVmaze, his last as a main-cast player. On IMDb it scores 7.7 from 252 votes.

Television Heaven's review of the series says Cadfael is usually left rather sad about it all at the end of a case, and that the films do not tidy everything up. A story that sets him against his closest friend is a test of that description.

Cast

  • Derek Jacobias Brother Cadfael
  • Terrence Hardimanas Abbot Radulfus
  • Michael Culveras Prior Robert
  • Julian Firthas Brother Jerome
  • Mark Charnockas Brother Oswin
  • Eoin McCarthyas Sheriff Hugh Beringar
  • Jacqueline Defferaryas Emma Vernold
  • Ben Pullenas Ivo Corbiere
  • Tim Wyltonas Geoffrey Corviser
  • Richard Cliffordas Glover of Shotwick
  • Brendan O'Heaas Philip Corviser
  • Albie Woodingtonas Sergeant Warden