A Cup of Crime

Cadfael · S04E01

The Holy Thief

First aired 1998-06-23 · Written by Ben Rostul · Directed by Ken Grieve

ByDavid

The Holy Thief puts a saint's bones in a bargain between two abbeys. Prior Herluin and his novice, Tutilo, arrive unannounced at Shrewsbury from Ramsey Abbey, which has just been destroyed in the civil war. Tutilo has had a vision of St Winifred, and Herluin takes it as a reason to ask for the loan of her relics. Shrewsbury has been receiving large donations from pilgrims since it acquired them, so Abbot Radulfus finds it hard to refuse.

Radulfus reluctantly agrees to lend the relics. Then a bequest arrives for Tutilo from Lady Donata, a necklace so valuable that Ramsey could be rebuilt with the proceeds, though that does not seem to have been what she meant. Radulfus decides he can keep the saint after all, but Herluin is not ready to give her up.

Then the relics vanish from the Abbey, together with the necklace and with Daalny, a singer who is a slave to a minstrel and a friend of Tutilo. The Abbot sends Cadfael to find them. He finds that Daalny has been abducted, and he finds her and the relics, but the necklace is gone. Soon the hireling who took Daalny and the valuables is found dead almost on Cadfael's doorstep, his head bashed in with a rock.

Wikipedia says that the film follows the main plot of Ellis Peters's novel but makes several changes. It leaves out the subplot of Herluin's attempt to recover a former novice, Sulien Blount, and it renames the murdered man Alfred, where the book calls him Aldhelm. It changes the identity of the murderer, replaces a psaltery with a jewelled necklace as Donata's gift, and makes Lord Beaumont far more arrogant, cynical and cruel than he is in the novel.

Ben Rostul wrote the film, his only one for the series, and Ken Grieve directed it. Anthony Green plays Hugh Beringar, the third actor in the part. George Irving plays Herluin, Richard Lintern plays Lord Beaumont, Benedict Sandiford plays Tutilo and Louise Delamere plays Daalny. Derek Jacobi leads, with Terrence Hardiman as Radulfus and Michael Culver and Julian Firth as Prior Robert and Brother Jerome.

It was shown on ITV on 23 June 1998, the first film of the fourth series and the first of any kind in the series for ten months. The other two films of the series followed in December. On IMDb it has a score of 7.6 from 215 votes.

Cast

  • Derek Jacobias Brother Cadfael
  • Terrence Hardimanas Abbot Radulfus
  • Michael Culveras Prior Robert
  • Julian Firthas Brother Jerome
  • Anthony Greenas Hugh Beringar
  • George Irvingas Herluin
  • Richard Linternas Lord Beaumont
  • Benedict Sandifordas Tutilo
  • Louise Delamereas Daalny
  • Frank Bakeras Remy
  • Natasha Pyneas Lady Donata