A Cup of Crime

Cadfael · S04E03

The Pilgrim of Hate

First aired 1998-12-28 · Written by Richard Stoneman · Directed by Ken Grieve

ByDavid

The Pilgrim of Hate is the last film in the series, and it starts with a body in a sack. The corpse of an elderly man is found hidden at Shrewsbury Abbey, and Brother Cadfael believes he was murdered. The chief suspects are a group of pilgrims, among whom are two known thieves. Cadfael locks them up in the hope of drawing out the killer.

IMDb's summary says the day draws many to Shrewsbury, including a few con artists, and calls it Cripples Day. The pilgrims have come for St Winifred's day, and a review of the Acorn DVD on DVD Talk describes them as a rag-tag bunch that includes charlatans who sell an endless supply of holy relics. The reviewer found the film reasonably entertaining but not outstanding as a mystery, and suggested renting it first.

Wikipedia says the film varies widely from Ellis Peters's novel, and an IMDb note says the plot bears almost no resemblance to it. In the book the question is a murder far away, and in the film the question is the dead man's identity. Matthew, who is called Luc in the film, and Ciaran are brothers, and each blames the other for their father's death.

In this version Luc is the villain. Rhun, called Walter, is a crippled man who confirms the Abbot's suspicion that he is faking his condition to earn the charity of people around him. His sister, Melangell, is forced by guilt to wait on him hand and foot, and she has even stolen to keep them.

Wikipedia adds that this was the last of Ellis Peters's novels to be adapted for the screen.

Richard Stoneman wrote the film, his only one for the series, and Ken Grieve directed it, his third. Matt Patresi plays Ciaran, Barney Craig plays Luc, Lee Ingleby plays Walter, Natasha Little plays Melangell and Terence Beesley plays Simeon Bagot. Anthony Green plays Hugh Beringar. Derek Jacobi leads, with Terrence Hardiman as Radulfus and Michael Culver and Julian Firth as Prior Robert and Brother Jerome.

The film was shown on ITV on 28 December 1998, five days after The Potter's Field. Wikipedia gives its audience as 6.24 million viewers, according to BARB, a little under the figure for the previous film. Wikipedia's table gives figures for only these two films. No further series followed, and thirteen of the twenty-one novels had been adapted. On IMDb the film scores 7.6 from 221 votes.

Cast

  • Derek Jacobias Brother Cadfael
  • Terrence Hardimanas Abbot Radulfus
  • Michael Culveras Prior Robert
  • Julian Firthas Brother Jerome
  • Anthony Greenas Hugh Beringar
  • Matt Patresias Ciaran
  • Barney Craigas Luc
  • Lee Inglebyas Walter
  • Natasha Littleas Melangell
  • Terence Beesleyas Simeon Bagot